Audiences at the book launch of The New Black Middle Class in South Africa expressed the need for a distinction to be made between the black elite and the black middle class.
A distinction needs to be made between the black elite and the black middle class. This emerged at the launch of The New Black Middle Class in South Africa, written by Professor Roger Southall, the head of the Sociology department at Wits.
This proposal by panellist Mosa Phadi followed on another by fellow panellist, Hlonipha Mokoena, whose view was that there were several black middle classes, and that “perhaps they all need their own study”.
Prof Southall said the book sought to dispel stereotypes such as the ‘corrupt tenderpreneurs’ narrative of the black middle class. Speaking at the launch, he said that he wished to illustrate that the black middle class were “ordinary people who managed to get themselves out of poverty”. The book looks into the role of education, affirmative action as well as the political stances of those identifying as the black middle class.
Some in attendance expressed concerns that it had taken a white male, Southall, to write about this “black story”. Bontle Moeketsi, a third year student from Wits said the author could not fully understand the subject. Buhle Vilane, a third year student from the University of Johannesburg said, “We have a voice but we don’t use it”. She also felt that a black chairperson would have been more appropriate for the occasion, rather than Professor Eddie Webster
When asked about the lack of black voices on the topic, Phadi said that black people were yet to fully explore the topic of class. She added that discussions on class were viewed as “anti-radical” because race remained a larger issue among black people.
The book seemed to have been received fairly well overall, with a couple of the panellists calling it a “good guideline”. Points were raised about how the book dealt loosely with topics such as ANC affiliation and the need to evolve the terminology to include South Africa-specific nuances. Mokoena referenced ‘start-ups’ and ‘amaTy-Ty’ (tycoons) as vocabulary terms that needed to be included in the discussion in order for the conversation to be fully reflective of the complex group termed ‘the black middle class’.
Wits Vuvuzela, Book Launch: Rape- A South African nightmare, March 4, 2016
Wits Vuvuzela, Reopening of Mandela’s personal archives celebrated with a book launch at Wits, May 6, 2016
Wits Vuvuzela, WITS NEWS: Book launch at WISER, April 17, 2013