Once legal representation disputes are settled, the infamous Grindr 7 will receive a trial date.
The Grindr 7 case was remanded again on August 12 to settle disputes regarding the legal representation of three of the accused. This comes after a spate of appearances and postponements to address the same issue since March 2024 in the Johannesburg Magistrate’s Court.
The seven accused, Sanele Ndlovu, 26, Vikani Khanyeza, 28, Sohollo Khumalo, 26, Sphamandla Mavundla, 33, Lungisani Shabalala, 33, Thulani Mazibuko, 23, and Khayelihle Zulu, 24, were arrested in late 2023 for the alleged kidnapping of a Wits University student using the LGBTQI+ dating app, Grindr.
The seven accused as they descend the steps to return to custody until their next date. Photo: Thato Gololo
Further charges were brought against the men for extortion and attempted murder as the state alleges that upon kidnapping the victim, the men held him for ransom of R30 000.
The case had previously been postponed on July 11, 2024, so that the state and the attorney for Ndlovu, Khanyeza and Khumalo could settle internal disputes regarding certain submissions made by the defense to the state.
According to the defense, these submissions were not addressed by the state, therefore the matter cannot proceed, yet the state refutes this, claiming they require written proof that these submissions were made in the first place.
Though these disputes linger, Magistrate Simon Radasi confirmed the trial readiness of all the parties. This means that all evidence has been submitted, and all witnesses have been listed and confirmed. Regardless, Magistrate Radasi irritation was clear. “My role is to sit here and listen to evidence. If this [dispute] is not settled within the next two weeks, I will hold an inquest. If [the inquest determines] the delay is unreasonable, it will go for trial.”
Many members of LGBTQI+ advocacy group, Parents, Families and Friends of South African Queers (PFSAQ) were in attendance, filling almost half of the public seating available.
They expressed the belief that the defense is employing delay tactics to avoid trial. “What we are happy about is that the magistrate is saying, ‘whether representation or no representation, the case will proceed to trial’,” says PFSAQ member Virginia Magwaza.
As bail was refused for all the accused, they will remain in custody and appear on August 29, 2024, to assess whether the dispute has been resolved and the case can proceed to trial.
FEATURED IMAGE: The Grindr 7 being informed of the proceedings by Magistrate Radasi. Photo: Thato Gololo
Concerns for the safety of dating-app users soar after the kidnapping of an 18-year-old student.
A Wits University student is recovering in hospital after being kidnapped by a group of men who had allegedly lured them through online dating app, Grindr.
The victim was found by police, bound and unconscious, on September 20 at the Denver Men’s Hostel and taken to Milpark Hospital for treatment. Seven suspects were arrested and charged with kidnapping and extortion, with police recovering three knives and the student’s belongings in their possession.
Police are investigating if the suspects have links to numerous other cases of a similar nature in Gauteng.
The student is currently staying at one of the university’s residences and on September 19, their roommate reported them missing after not returning from meeting with someone from the app.
“A Wits warden informed [Campus Protection Services (CPS)] that a student was reported missing by his roommate,” said Wits spokesperson Shirona Patel. CPS then immediately alerted the South African Police Department (SAPS). “They worked to track down the student… CPS were a central part of this team and acted swiftly,” added Patel. The university says that this is the first case of this nature that they have been made aware of.
The kidnappers contacted the student’s family and demanded tens of thousands of rands in ransom money.
SAPS Gauteng spokesperson Brenda Muridili said that a large group working together to recover the student were led “to an ATM where one of the suspects was expected to withdraw the ransom money on the M2 Road. The police held an observation and then placed the suspect under arrest [as] soon as he arrived.” The suspect then led the police to the hostel.
Grindr is a popular social networking and online dating app that sees around 3.6 million online daily users worldwide. The app is targeted towards the queer community (mostly men – 69% of users) looking for, as the AfroQueer podcast describes it, “hookups, relationships and love… and some other things in-between.”
However, this app has been an ever increasing medium to facilitate organised crime.
There have been numerous cases where users have been targeted by people who robbed, assaulted, raped, kidnapped and/or murdered them. The app itself issued a warning to its South African users over the rise in kidnapping’s linked to their own platform earlier this year.
A screenshot of the Grindr homepage in January 2023, issuing a “Johannesburg Safety Warning” due to the rise of kidnappings around the city that targeted its users. Image: MambaOnline.com
Noma Sibanda, who is a representative from LQBTQIA+ rights-oriented society Activate Wits, said that the “app itself is not safe because anyone can open a fake account”. There is no verification process when opening a Grindr account and anonymity is synonymous with most profiles, largely due to stigma, which criminals take advantage of.
“When speaking to someone romantically, people can be misled easily… so when meeting up for the first time with someone on the app, do so in a public place with other people,” said Sibanda.
Activate Wits says that this event “not only causes physical or psychological harm but also perpetuates a culture of silence and fear… [Criminal syndicates] capitalise on this because it is easier in South Africa to be operational because they believe they can get away with it,” added Sibanda.
Sibanda hopes to work closely with the university for victims to come forward and report crimes as “it may be easier for the queer community to speak (and open up) to others in the community”.
FEATURED IMAGE: Student activists pose on the Library Lawns while facing the Wits Great Hall. Photo: File
Societal expectations and experiences can often place pressure on people’s relationships. With Valentine’s Day coming up we have asked individuals questions about their views on certain relationship dynamics especially when it comes to the most anticipated day of the year for some lovers, Valentines Day. Viewers shared their beliefs and Siyanda and Katlego talk about […]
