The 2024 index was released today and the South African National Editors Forum looks at the country’s media landscape and its challenges.
In 2024, South Africa ranked 38th worldwide for press freedom, this is according to the World Press Freedom Index. This year’s ranking was informed by the increasing issue of low funding for media outlets, which has greatly impacted news production in the country.
The World Press Freedom Index (WPFI) is a grading of countries by Reporters Without Borders (RSF) released annually on World Press Freedom Day. It is based on their assessment of each country’s press freedom records for the year prior.
These rankings paint a partial picture of the journalism landscape across the world annually; and help to identify countries with the least press freedom. In 2022, RSF altered the index methodology from what was used between 2013 to 2021. The new methodology centred on six main categories: pluralism, media independence, media environment and self-censorship, legislative framework, transparency, and the quality of the infrastructure that supports the production of news and information.
In the continent, South Africa has ranked well, oftentimes reaching the second highest position. RSF states it is because “South Africa guarantees press freedom and has a well-established culture of investigative journalism” but is hindered by the fact that journalists are often the subject of attacks by political leaders. However, in 2024 the ranking has decreased to 38 from 25 .
Speaking to Wits Vuvuzela about the state of journalism in the country, Reggy Moalusi, the executive director of the South African National Editors Forum (SANEF), believes that South Africa has a robust press environment: “Over the years [South African Journalism] has proven itself to be among the best in the world, particularly when it comes to questioning the public and private sectors.”
Moalusi notes that the landscape could be better especially “from a point of view of how journalists are treated and [the] continuous and rising bullying online of journalists, particularly female ones.” This time last year, a documentary recounting the extensive harassment towards female journalists was released entitled Section 16, which takes its name from section 16 of the constitution.
Seasoned journalist and editor, Candice Bailey, said that since 2024 is a prominent election year, electioneering may play a prominent role in our ranking in the coming year. She reflected on news reports that Moshoeshoe Monare, the group executive of SABC had been intimidated by the State Security Agency over the weekend.
Aside from social media, another avenue for the harassment and silencing of journalists is the legal system. In a secret court application, the Moti Group interdicted amaBhungane from using leaked confidential documents to expose their illicit mining ventures.
While unfortunate, Moalusi believes these instances shows the resilience of journalists as they continue to tell South African stories despite the attacks. “Media freedom embedded in journalism is our greatest tool.
“[We] need journalists to feel protected by the law”, said Bailey. She believes that the court victory by Karyn Maughan against former President Jacob Zuma will reflect positively in this year’s evaluations.
Infrastructure could potentially bring down South Africa’s ranking. South Africa is plagued by a financial crisis that does not seem to be improving. It came to a head this past year when Independent Media, the owners of publications such as The Star and The Cape Times, retrenched 128 employees, yet was still unable to pay severance packages on time. Less than a month ago, Daily Maverick shut down their entire website to highlight what they call a “state of emergency in journalism” where more than 70% of journalists have left the field.
The future is not all bleak. Moalusi shared that SANEF is launching a Journalist Sustainability Fund to “raise revenue to invest back into newsrooms.” He mentions that even though it is still in the developmental stage, “several companies and stakeholders have been receptive to the idea so we hope by the time we start raising our hands, corporate South Africa will respond.” Therefore, no matter the constraints, the passion felt by journalists will continue fueling robust, independent and thorough journalism and that will be reflected in this year’s rankings.
FEATURED IMAGE: Graphic: Adobe Stock
RELATED ARTICLES:
- Wits Vuvuzela, Wits shrugs off pressure, screens Modi documentary, May 2023
- Wits Vuvuzela, Mixed feelings about World Press Freedom Day, May 2019
- Wits Vuvuzela, Menell13: Media freedom unpacked, June 2013
