Exchange students weigh in on South Africa’s fractured relationship with Trump’s America

The declining diplomatic relationship between the United States and South Africa makes for a complex and self-introspective experience for American students in Johannesburg.

With one post on X on February 3, the bilateral relationship between the United States of America (USA) and South Africa was fractured.

US President Donald Trump posted an accusation claiming that the South African government is engaging in discriminatory behaviour towards white South Africans and turning a blind eye to the “human rights violations” occurring in the country.

Trump went on to announce his plan to withhold all funding from the nation – a promise he has fulfilled while making further untruthful claims about South Africa.

Despite the future of the bilateral relationship between the United States and South Africa being unknown, tourism and education continue to bring Americans to the country.

Wits Vuvuzela spoke to some American students living and studying in Johannesburg to get a sense of how they feel being American in Johannesburg in this unprecedented time.

Sahar Carter, a Californian native pursuing their master’s degree in creative writing, said, “I personally don’t see myself as an ambassador of my nation.

“My criticism of the US also spurred me wanting [sic] to come to South Africa.”

Carter’s Johannesburg experience during this time has birthed a desire in her to explore the specifics of her African roots.

“I do feel like since being here I’ve felt emboldened to become an ambassador for black Americans, I guess I feel very defensive about my culture,” they said.

Carter’s defensiveness also stems from their realisation of a perception from some South Africans, expressed especially on social media platforms, about African Americans being ignorant and stupid.

They attribute the sentiment to Africa’s misrepresentation in American media and the fact that the average American interacts with ‘censored’ media.

“ We don’t easily have ways of hearing about the rest of the world that doesn’t filter through specifically American media,” said Carter.

American students from a joint exchange program between Pitzer College in California and Wits University under the University’s Centre for Diversity studies also shared their thoughts.

Feven Aklilu , an American student of Ethiopian descent, opened up about her experience of never truly feeling American until she was confronted with the reality of the state of her nation while living in Johannesburg.

“Being in this space and trying to figure that out has made it very glaringly apparent that as much as I view myself separate from America and its problems and the consequences it brings, I’m still a living manifestation of that when I’m here and there’s a weird sense of not wanting to interact with that,” she said.

Another member of the programme, Laine May says she finds that South Africans become more receptive to connecting once they figure out their respective political standings.

“Conversations open up once they realise, oh you’re not that kind of American or whatever the current idea of what an American is.”

Laine says that she doesn’t feel sad about actively disassociating from her American identity, but finds sadness in the idea that being American is now associated with the qualities of its current administration.

She also felt disheartened after taking note of the way the United States is still romanticised in educational spaces in Southern Africa and how that contributes to Africa’s “brain drain”.

“As an American, I wish the American dream was something that was real for me and is a possibility for these children that want something bigger than they have now,” she said.

Despite these sentiments, the consensus among the American students interviewed was that they enjoy living in Johannesburg and that this experience is one that will change their perspectives as American students for life.

FEATURED IMAGE: An illustration of the flags of the United States and South Africa slightly overlapping, with the Johannesburg skyline at the bottom. Graphic: Sechaba Molete

RELATED ARTICLES:

REVIEW: Jazz Tuesday’s at Wits

A new musical weekly incentive to get over blue Mondays.

“I love you all and I’ll, see you here next week!” Those were the parting words of Carlo Mombeli, associate professor and the head of Wits University’s Music department. Mombeli’s words were not only an indicator of the intimate feel of the room but also a reflection of his intentions.

Wits Jazz Tuesday’s is a weekly musical showcase put on at the Wits theatre lobby by the students and staff of the university’s music department.

Writing this, I felt like a miner who had just discovered gold or a scientist who had just uncovered the inner workings of one of Earth’s many mysteries.

Two audience members performing an item. Photo: Sechaba Molete

The night was ushered in with the cry of the first musicians trumpet. At that moment, the theatre lobby turned into a terminal with the audience members being passengers eagerly awaiting a journey that transcended space and time.  

Words cannot adequately substitute the feeling of physically being present at the feet of a live music ensemble, but in my attempt to use a linguistic medium, I would describe Wits Jazz Tuesdays as a place for community.

The Wits Jazz Tuesday community survives off an ecosystem made of jazz lovers, musicians (instrumentalists and vocalists) and aspiring musicians. Mombeli’s hands-on approach to leading this weekly musical gathering further strengthens its community feel, with him encouraging audience members to showcase any of their musical abilities while he volunteered one of his students to back them up.

The tapping of shoes on the ground, the nodding of heads, the closing of eyes and the occasional yelling of inaudible sounds were all markers of a common understanding and appreciation of the jazz genre.

The programme began with pure jazz and improvisation by specific student bands selected in advance. As the evening progresses and audience members are invited to perform, genres such as indie pop and alternative music become more frequent.

The evening struck the right balance between indulging the tastes of jazz fanatics and virtuosos while catering to the tastes of music lovers in general.

Wits Jazz Tuesday’s was an interactive experience that demanded engagement. Midway through the programme- Mombelli asked everyone to participate in creating the evening’s soundtrack by mumbling in a specific tone. Despite the awkward giggles and concerned comments that followed this request, Mombelli remained committed to democratising jazz and its creation.

This was further reflected in his decision to make the showcase free and invite everyone to join him and his students again next week. It was a fun and heartwarming experience. Its inclusive nature is reassuring and relaxing. The weekly showcase on Tuesday evenings serves as a reward for surviving Mondays!

I would give it a solid 9/10.

FEATURED IMAGE: An image of Wits University’s music students performing a song

RELATED ARTICLES:

New Mpox variant found in South Africa

A new health scare rears its head as faster spreading variant makes its way to the country.

A new, highly infectious variant of the Mpox virus called, Clade 1b has officially reached South African shores, with Gauteng being its landing ground. Unlike the previous variant (Clade 2) Clade b1 is spread through mucus, bodily fluids, skin to skin contact and coughing.

According to a statement released by the National Institute of Communicable Diseases (NICD) in March 2025, seven labs in Gauteng had reported to have detected the new variant.

“We tend to let our guard down at times. When you look at a lot of viruses, all that they need us to do is be vigilant and avoid contact with infected people”, said Tshidiso Ntshabele, Wits University’s campus health and wellness head. According to Ntshabele, with the help of the Wits campus health and wellness center’s Infection Prevention and control policy, the center would be prepared if the spread of the virus escalated.

Infographic showing the nature of the new variant and how to prevent it from spreading. Photo: Created on Canva.

South Africa is not the first African country to experience a breakout of the new variant. The city of Kampala in Uganda was one of the places in which the first South African Clade b1 patient had just visited before it was discovered in Gauteng. As it stands the NICD has traced two groups of the virus with the first group being traced to the patient who had recently visited Kampala and the second group being traced to a similar area in Gauteng.

“I would advise students to familiarize themselves with the signs and symptoms of viruses, and most importantly always avoid contact with someone who might think has any kind of virus,” says Ntshabele.

These are the very same sentiments held by the NICD as there is currently no cure or vaccine for the Mpox virus or its new variant.